A modern Long Island seafood house New American Tavern serving fresh local seafood right Off The Bay.A menu rooted in fresh, local ingredients and coastal influence. Experience vibrant seafood, refined classics, and bold flavors—all served with a modern edge.A lineup of craft cocktails, each artfully mixed with fresh ingredients.From laid back gatherings to high energy celebrations, Off The Bay is where great food, crafted cocktails, and unforgettable moments come together. There is always something happening here in the heart of Sayville.